Key takeaways
- Debt was once the primary driver of buyout returns, but its contribution to performance has fallen significantly as deal structures have become more conservative.
- Rather than generating returns through high levels of borrowing, managers increasingly focus on improving businesses through operational changes, strategic repositioning and growth initiatives.
- Manager skill matters more than ever. As higher valuations and larger equity contributions limit the benefits of leverage, successful outcomes depend increasingly on a manager's ability to execute buy-and-build strategies, grow portfolio companies and create long-term value.
Buyouts: Less leverage, more action
LBOs have propelled private equity, and private markets more broadly, to the status of a recognised asset class. They use debt to acquire companies, with future profits servicing the debt, but this creates significant risk given the uncertainty around future cash flows and company values.
The first wave of LBOs relied on very high leverage, with some mega deals financed by over 90% debt. Fund managers focused on unlocking value by acquiring and restructuring conglomerates, fuelling perceptions that LBOs loaded companies with excessive debt, cut costs and sold assets, leaving employees jobless and stakeholders empty-handed.
During the following decades, managers shifted their focus towards creating value through operational improvements, professionalisation and strategic repositioning. Meanwhile, the proportion of equity in LBOs increased from 27% in 1987 to 48% in 2025. Since 2019, debt-to-equity ratios in large deals have averaged 55% to 45%, while smaller ones use less leverage.
As a result, the contribution of financial leverage to LBO performance decreased from 46% between 1986 and 2000 to 22% between 2008 and 2018. During this time, operational improvements and EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization) growth became more important drivers of returns.
Higher valuations and equity contributions raise questions about future performance. Managers have responded by expanding their use of ‘buy and build’ strategies, acquiring a platform company and then making smaller add-on acquisitions at lower valuations and with less leverage. While this approach can improve value creation, it also leads to longer holding periods. To return capital to investors more quickly, managers may at times re-leverage portfolio companies through dividend recapitalisations. While this can boost internal rates of return, it also increases risk.
The wonders of financial leverage, and its limits
The emergence of LBOs began after World War II with McLean Industries’ 1955 acquisitions of Pan-Atlantic Steamship Corporation and Waterman Steamship Corporation, transactions often cited as the first leveraged buyout in history.
In acquiring these companies, McLean Industries applied a technique similar to a buy-to-let real estate purchase, using USD 42 million of debt and USD 7 million of equity, resulting in a debt-to-equity ratio of 85% to 15%. Future profits from the two companies were then used to repay principal and interest.
The transaction stood out because collateral was unusual. Rather than hard assets, lenders relied on the companies and their assets as security. This increased risk because future cash flows and collateral values were uncertain.

Cyril Demaria-Bengochéa, Head of Private Markets Strategy and Research
The success of the deal paved the way for similar transactions and the first wave of LBOs culminated in 1989 when KKR acquired RJR Nabisco for USD 24.8 billion (USD 31.4 billion including assumed debt), the largest LBO in history until 2007.
Although the transaction was ultimately unsuccessful, it left a lasting negative impression on the public. The term ‘LBO’ itself fell out of favour in the US, as fund managers increasingly rebranded themselves as ‘private equity’ operators.
However, this transaction not only marked a peak in deal size, a record that stood for almost two decades, but also the end of an era. Over the following two decades, fund managers shifted their attention towards value creation, a trend that is continuing today.
Conclusion
The evolution of LBOs shows that private equity is no longer primarily a leverage story. While debt remains an important tool, fund managers increasingly rely on operational improvements, acquisitions and business transformation to generate returns. As higher valuations and stricter lending conditions limit the benefits of financial engineering, manager skill and value creation have become more important drivers of performance.
Related Articles
Beyond Bordeaux: Redrawing the wine map
- 16.07.2026
- Private Markets
- 5 min