Prof. María Luisa Méndez, what is social mobility?
"Social mobility refers to the transition from one position to another within a society. While upward mobility implies moving up in social class, downward mobility entails moving down to a lower status. A successful upward trajectory can either lead to an economic gain or a gain in decision-making power. Both transitions have one thing in common: the change in status allows a change in access. People of higher status have greater access to valuable resources within a society. And due to its multidimensional nature, the value of higher status is also immensely symbolic. A person of an upper class is more likely to be recognised and credited. This fact adds to the unequal opportunities and obstacles that people of a lower socio-economic status face."
Why is it vital for a society to allow or even foster social mobility?
"In the past, according to the concept of meritocracy, resources were distributed based on effort and talent. Social hierarchies were accepted as they followed the belief that those who worked hard would be offered more resources. Currently, it is becoming apparent that meritocracy is not working as expected. The frustration of this empty promise lingers in large groups of society, especially in the Global South. People working incessantly are deprived of changing their situation while wealth is accumulating at the top – a fact often referred to as the ‘broken elevator of social mobility’. The political tensions resulting from these dynamics pave the way for unrest as key political and social institutions are discredited."
What obstacles impede moving upward?
"The causes of unequal opportunities are multidimensional and complex. One obstacle is the increased competitiveness within the labour market. One’s qualifications are even more essential today than they were in the past. Secondly, some industries and economic sectors are nearly entirely inhabited by the dominant group, which tends to recruit peers rather than people outside their social class. A reason for this tendency lies in the unawareness of how subjectively a person views other people. A beautiful smile on a résumé picture stands for being able to afford expensive dental work, for example. Excellent references imply a powerful network to call on. A self-confident demeanour during an interview hints that the contestant was encouraged during childhood. All these indicators nourish a sense of confidence when hiring this person in contrast to pioneering with a ‘new’ contestant. Our interviews further substantiated that the embodied cultural capital (see box below) significantly affects how easy or difficult moving upward becomes."
‘Embodied Cultural Capital’
Different socio-economic groups tend to have and afford different lifestyles. This commonly crystallises in the language used, the places visited, and everyday routines: Being part of a social class inevitably means knowing a series of symbols and certain conducts. It is called ‘embodied cultural capital’. Many participants noted feeling out of place when they started a higher-paying job or moved to a better area of town. They started feeling detached from their own roots, raising questions of self-identity. And sometimes, a resulting modesty makes them hesitate in moments when they should be putting themselves forward.
Consequently, what would facilitate a ‘social mobility-friendly’ society?
"If a society becomes more aware of the obstacles as a collectively shared and experienced phenomenon, it can actively shape a mobility-friendly environment. The private sector has a significant role to play in this respect. We plan to share our results, especially with the recruiting teams of big corporations. When we see the recruitment process through the lens of social mobility, upwardly mobile employees and collaborators can be incorporated more naturally for both parties.
Social mobility is not merely a result of quality education or fair opportunities. When we consider the cultural and affective aspects, it becomes evident how deeply collective this phenomenon is. We cannot see it simply as an individual journey of a single person. The ability to move up in society requires a whole community to act accordingly and openly."
The Julius Baer Foundation
Our vision
We envision a future where the disadvantaged and the privileged work together to create opportunities and share in a more equitable world.
Our mission
We are committed to reducing inequalities in wealth, education, and opportunity.
- Wealth disparities go beyond money. We support projects that empower all those involved to work across the wealth divide towards courageous solutions and a sharing of knowledge, networks, and opportunities.
- Education builds self-confidence and new perspectives. We educate on the perils of inequality and motivate the next generation to contribute actively towards levelling the playing field in their communities.
- Our projects aim to create dialogues across the wealth divide, between the privileged and the disadvantaged. In the spirit of our Foundation, both parties commit to active cooperation based on mutual respect and trust to kick-start truly sustainable innovation and pave the way for a society that provides equal opportunities for all.
Our values
- Courage: We have the courage to support visionary partner organisations and recognise their potential.
- Motivation: We take a motivational approach to collaborating with our partners and stakeholders on an equal footing.
- Sharing: We believe in the power of sharing our knowledge, our expertise, and our network.
Related Link
Julius Baer Foundation
The Julius Baer Foundation supports the Bank’s purpose of creating value beyond wealth by contributing to a more equitable world. In this series, we present the foundation's projects and initiatives.